• Please review our updated Terms and Rules here

dec newbie questions

hitachi

Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2012
Messages
49
Location
Bellevue, NE
Hi.
I'm relatively new to vintage computing and I'm thinking about getting a DEC machine.

I'm hoping that I could be pointed to a beginner's guide or be helped with my questions...

What model would be best to look for, for a noob?
What all does one of these machines need to work?
What should I expect to pay for a working set up?

Any help is appreciated

Thanks
Adam
 
First of all are you thinking PDP-8 or PDP-11 or VAX or something else? A VAX running VMS is probably the easiest and least expensive start in most cases.
 
I always wanted one myself, but what would I ever do with it besides stand bewildered in amazement at the blinkenlichtens! xD
 
Last edited:
I was originally thinking along the lines of pdp-8 or pdp-11... I guess I'm not familiar with VAX yet...

Hmm... PDP-8 or PDP-11... that narrows it down to about 100 models.

I'll re-sequence your questions a little, and restrict myself to the PDP-11's. (Someone else will advise about others)



  • What all does one of these machines need to work?

Models were available in many countries, and had differing power capabilities. It would be important to know where you live to answer this.

Also, models ranged from Desktop to Floor Stand to Rack Mount to Refrigerator size [Sub-Zero if you please] and consumed hundreds to ten-thousands of watts. [more if multiple large disk and tape drives were in use]

Power needs ranged from simple 110VAC 1PH to 220VAC 3PH, depending on which. Most systems were 50 or 60 hz operable. Amperage from 20A to 600A, again - depending on overall system size and to some degree, age.

Older disk drives are becoming more and more of a problem to get supplies and parts for. Moreover, removable cartridge drives required routine preventative maintenance - air filters, brushes, bearings and spindles etc... all of which are now unavailable and are critical to fault free operation. Fail to perform PMs and your drives will quickly become inoperable, and your media permanently physically damaged. RL media for example, although rugged, can be damaged to the point where it's original format has been overwritten, and this cannot be subsequently re-formatted. RM or RP drives and media are more rare and even more maintenance dependent.

Smaller machines had only "comfortable" atmospheric and Air Conditioning needs, where larger systems required CTCH of a more rigorous nature.

One attribute often not considered is system weight. Hardly any older systems weigh less than hundreds of pounds - if not thousands. Newer, more common "Floor Stand" types with self contained media probably weigh in mostly in the sub 100 LB range, but almost always over ~50 LBS.


  • What should I expect to pay for a working set up?

The sky is pretty much the limit these days. It seems if you've the patience, you can still piece a system together for hundreds to thousands. Complete systems of the larger (and older) physical variety come along less and less frequently nowadays and I would expect to be able to land them for Thousands to Ten-Thousands depending on the rarity, condition and completeness of the system.



  • What model would be best to look for, for a noob?

Here's the real issue - PDP-11's are like Real Estate... they ain't makin any more, so you'll be better off buying sooner than later. If you have the resources, jumping in at the deep end of the pond now will save you much more money than if you wait till you're experienced - down the road.

On the other hand, it's easy to make costly mistakes, both in purchasing and use. We cry a lot when noob mistakes destroy equipment - which is very easy to do - and anyone can "get taken advantage of", in a sale.



Operating Systems:


You haven't mentioned a purpose to your interest, or any specific software you'd like to be able to run. A museum for example, would be safe going for a large system with lots of variety of memory and media and be fairly secure in the knowledge that they could run any DEC Operating System of appropriate vintage with suitable hardware and options.

On the other hand, if for example your interest was primarily in early Bell Labs UNIX OS's, the required minimum hardware set would be considerably less difficult to collect.

If the OS is not on your radar as yet, a good general purpose "Single User" system for a novice would be RT-11. It's compatible with the broadest range of hardware configurations and is readily available over the internet. It also supports a pretty good smattering of devices and languages so will be "usable".

UNIX support of hardware varies quite a bit with the vintage, as one would expect. However, once running - expectations are more easily met because of it's longevity and current use in todays world [as long as your comfortable with a text user interface]

RSX seems to be of little interest to the hobbyist, and I do not recommend it unless you want to delve into the attributes of early, Multi-User, preemptive, realtime OSs. However if your interest does lie here, RSX is a most sophisticated OS and exceeds complexity of many more modern counterparts. [IMHO]

There are other OSs too, RSTS, CAPS-11, and more. Also a pre-OS type software can be fascinating to study too.



A quick guide to PDP-11 Models:


  • In the beginning, DEC created UNIBUS, and it was good.


  • DEC added more bits to the UNIBUS, and it prospered. (up to 18 bits)


  • Then DEC created Memory Management and Mapped Systems were born. The king of these being the PDP-11/70 - a PDP-11 CPU with Supervisory Execution modes that accessed 32-bit memory via CACHE and contained separate I/O buses. 1 UNIBUS and up to 4 MASSBUSes. PDP-11/74 s could contain up to 4 such CPUs.


  • In general, PDP-11's are distinguished by the BUS type - UNIBUS and QBUS (first called LSI-11 bus)


  • Early CPUs were implemented in discreet LS logic. Most of these had console "Switch Registers". Later, CPUs were implemented using custom LSI and VLSI and then an early form of VLSI HCMOS. Their front panels dropped the Lamp / Switch Register in favor of requiring and inclusion of a Serial Console Terminal.

Eventually a CPU type numbering system evolved where even numbered models were UNIBUS and odd numbered ones were QBUS. Unfortunately, early systems violate this thinking, for example - an 11/02 was a QBUS machine constructed with LSI [Large Scale Integrated Circuits] where an 11/05 was UNIBUS consisting of discreet IC logic. Likewise the 11/45 was UNIBUS.

Also, a timeline of Systems will be confusing. The model numbers denoted families, based on capability - not necessarily sequence. An 11/70 was first available much earlier than it's numeric value might imply. An 11/03 came much later.

Lastly, the Family notion is to be taken more literally on PDP-11's than perhaps on any other computer. Software which ran on earlier machines, almost always ran unaltered on later models with more instructions and capabilities. This was known as "Upward Compatibility", and was a novel architectural asset not often found in other systems of the time. Device controllers for UNIBUS were often so compatible with their QBUS counterpart, that no customization of software drivers was required to run in either environment. Truly, a "Family" approach in many dimensions.



Ok, that's enough writing. If I haven't scared you off - supply us some feedback to get a useful line of discussion going.
 
Last edited:
Your best choice to start your exploration is not real hardware, but a software simulator called SIMH. It simulates a wide range of DEC (and other) hardware models, from the PDP-1 thru the PDP-8 to the PDP-11 series and even PDP-10 and various VAX-11 models. With this software you can explore the range of what the various DEC systems can do. You may decide a PDP-8 is just not for you, and a PDP-11 or a small VAX is just what you want to try and acquire.

I have a real PDP-11/44, on which I can run 2.11BSD unix, DEC RT-11 single user operating system, or DEC RSTS/E multiuser operating system.

I also use SIMH (http://simh.trailing-edge.com/) to run the EXACT SAME disk images that I use on the real hardware. And by the way SIMH running on a mid-to-high end Windows PC is somewhere in the neighborhood of 5X to 10X faster than the real legacy hardware (useful when doing unix sysgens).

Any software packages you might run on a real PDP-8 or PDP-11 or VAX can run on SIMH, so you can get up and running tomorrow with a true legacy 'antique' computing environment. And then when you know what you want (and don't want) you can go spend some serious disposable $$.

And of course SIMH is totally free, and will run on Windows or Linux, as you desire.

Don
 
Last edited:
Thanks Don... AK6DN is quite right. I myself use Ersatz-11 (www.dbit.com) a Software based PDP-11 emulation app that outperforms original hardware many times over.

I often use it to develop tools to assist users here on the forums, particularly to emulate hardware systems which I no longer physically possess.
 
Thanks for all the input. I think I'll fiddle around with one of the emulators and then decide what I want to do.

In truth, I just really want a huge piece of power-sucking hardware that looks awesome, and that I could actually perform some sort of task with. I've entertained the idea of a refurb IBM zseries but I didn't think it would be as fun as a pdp 11 or 8.
 
LOL - Ancient Machine worship is common in these parts. No point in trying to be practical about a fondness for das-blinkinlights und toggleswitches - they are artifacts out of the past and deserve our stewardship.

Fortunately for you, a lot of documentation exists online for these old systems. Often, to the level of schematics, theories of operation and programming details. You won't be accustomed to the availability of these for devices of our modern era, but for old DEC equipment it was the norm, and it's quality was outstanding. Internet sharing has made it possible to preserve these documents and systems long beyond any lifetime we could have originally expected.

As a result, many of these old systems not only exist into our present time, but are operational if not actually providing useful service. I would estimate possibly as many as 10% of the survivors are still functional if they were powered. It's a moot point from the aspect of applications software, for the most part. There are still pockets of need unfulfilled by other "modern" systems here and there, but the vast majority have been replaced or supplanted

I'm sure this community will still exist if and when you get ready to jump in. Perhaps you'll want to avail yourself of a Hamfest or other gathering to "touch actual iron" and adjust your sights on a particular target which satisfies.

Good luck, and "Welcome to the party, pal".
 
A good starter system for less than a thousand dollars...pdp 11/05, 11/10, or 11/34. Use a laptop for a serial terminal and also as a emulator to do the papertape and or disk storage. I feel like a simple VAX is OK but not as vintage.

You'll need to find someone to help you get started so you ideally want to find someone with the same system as you, nearby.

Set up an emulator so you can compare the actual system you have.

I recently bought a 11/34 with rl02 drive and cables for $150...sold it to a friend for $150. No room! If you network within various vintage computer clubs in person or online you can meet people who will sell you something at insider prices...ebay is retail and pricey.
 
Last edited:
If anyone has one to offer, I'd be interested getting my feet wet with a smaller PDP machine like the type Bill mentioned, maybe a complete and working 11/34 in good condition or smaller 11/23. Something I could get started with before trying to tackle an older one that might require more experience and knowledge.
 
Last edited:
If anyone has one to offer, I'd be interested getting my feet wet with a smaller PDP machine like the type Bill mentioned, maybe a complete and working 11/34 in good condition or smaller 11/23. Something I could get started with before trying to tackle an older one that might require more experience and knowledge.

I wish I did. I got rid of most of my pdp-11 and all my pdp-8 stuff before I moved to the Southwest. Now being back east I'd like to find
a small pdp-8e again if I can. The only 11 I have is my 11/84. A bit bigger than you are looking for.
Tim
 
I wish I did. I got rid of most of my pdp-11 and all my pdp-8 stuff before I moved to the Southwest. Now being back east I'd like to find
a small pdp-8e again if I can. The only 11 I have is my 11/84. A bit bigger than you are looking for.
Tim

How big is your 11/84? If it's manageable and you ever want to let it go, let me know :)
 
The /84 is fairly large.

100_1595.jpg
 
Back
Top